How do we price outcomes when we often don’t own the events that drive the client’s business result.

My day started with a question from a CEO of a 100-person creative & media agency:

“How do we price outcomes when we often don’t own the full chain of events that drive the client’s business result?”

It’s a question I hear a lot—especially from integrated agencies that sit somewhere between brand strategy and activation.

They create incredible work that shapes markets and moves people, but they don’t run sales, e-commerce, or distribution. So when trying to price for “business outcomes,” it can feel risky.

Here’s how I replied:

When I say “outcomes,” I don’t mean the ultimate business KPIs like revenue, market share, or CLV—those lagging indicators are rarely fully in an agency’s control.

I mean the leading indicators you can credibly influence that predict those results.

Things like:

  • Increased brand consideration or preference

  • Higher engagement or trial adoption

  • Improved marketing efficiency or conversion velocity

Those are measurable outcomes and often, the most powerful proof of your agency’s impact.

In our work, we teach teams to define a Scope of Value before a scope of work. It helps identify:

  • What the agency can own

  • What it can influence

  • And what sits outside its control

That clarity changes pricing conversations entirely. It moves the discussion from “how much effort will this take?” to “how much change can we create?”

It’s also the foundation for true value-based partnerships—where the agency and client can confidently tie compensation to outcomes that both sides can stand behind.

You don’t have to control every business result to price for outcomes. You just have to define the ones you can credibly create.

This post is part of our “FAQ Series,” where I share real questions from agency leaders and my answers. Have a question you’d like answered? Send it over.

Brian Kessman

Brian Kessman works with agency leaders who are ready to think differently and unlock their firm’s full growth potential.

As Lodestar's founder and principal consultant, Brian helps agencies move beyond billable hours and commoditized services to scalable, profitable models centered on client outcomes.

His strategies tackle the toughest agency growth challenges: redefining market position to attract premium clients; developing value-led pricing approaches to increase deal size; and creating diverse revenue streams for predictable income.

His programs deliver results. A full-service agency nearly doubled revenue from premium clients (from 36% to 73%) and increased overall income by 39%. A content agency grew a retainer deal size by 50%. Other firms boosted margins by optimizing their client mix, redesigning their offerings, and modernizing operations.

Brian is an inaugural member of the 4As Expert Network, and his transformative approach has been shared across the industry through presentations for Mirren, the 4A’s, AMIN, Magnet, Worldcom, and other top industry organizations. Combining hands-on and advisory expertise, he is a trusted partner to leadership teams looking to break free from outdated models and thrive in an era of disruption.

Previous
Previous

The Four Archetypes of the Agency Value Compass™